The Media Guide Perspective
Consultancies quietly taking decisions that should sit with leadership. Google and Meta’s ad refund practices under fire. Retail media networks bending attribution rules in their own favour. This is where we take a position, not just report the news.
We’ve argued that generative AI isn’t inherently good or bad for your business, just badly implemented most of the time. That LLMs have real limits marketers keep ignoring in the rush to adopt them. That most martech turf wars are self-inflicted, and that the middle manager everyone wants to cut is usually the one holding the operating model together. If you want a take, not just a summary of what happened, this is the archive.
An opinion is a starting point, not an answer
Business Challenges
Where these arguments show up as actual problems we’re brought in to solve.
See the challenges >Media Calculators
Model reach, revenue and media budgets before you act on any of this.
Use the calculators >Media & Marketing Glossary
If a term in one of these pieces is unfamiliar, it’s probably in here.
Browse the glossary >Services
MarTech, data and AI governance, growth and media operations, when an opinion isn’t enough.
See our services >The Standing Arguments Behind This Column
Individual pieces here cover different topics, but a handful of positions recur because the same underlying pattern keeps showing up across different problems.
- Platform self-reporting needs independent verification. Whoever sells the media and measures whether it worked has a structural incentive problem, regardless of intent. See Retail Media and Attribution.
- Opacity is the actual risk, not the pricing model. Vague answers about a new fee or monetisation layer are informative on their own. See Unraveling the SaaS Proposals of Magnite and PubMatic.
- Retention beats acquisition once acquisition gets structurally harder. The economics shift, not just the fashion. See Why Retention Stops At Loyalty.
- Accountability should never quietly transfer to an outside party. True of consultancies, true of vendors, true of any engagement structure. See When Consultancies Overwhelm Business Leadership.
Three Ways To Read This Archive, Depending On Why You’re Here
Different visitors land on this archive for different reasons. A quicker way in than scrolling the full list below.
| If you’re… | Start with |
|---|---|
| Evaluating a platform or vendor before committing spend | Unraveling the SaaS Proposals of Magnite and PubMatic, then Retail Media and Attribution |
| Building a business case for a martech or operating model change | Why Good Teams Fail When the Operating Model Is Wrong, then Martech Turf Wars |
| Catching up on what’s changed in privacy and identity | The Role of Adtech in the Privacy Sandbox Era, then How to Balance Data Privacy and Marketing Attribution |
What The M&A Wave Means For Who’s Actually Accountable
Adtech and martech M&A ran hot through 2025, roughly 465 deals, up 13% on the year, headlined by Omnicom’s acquisition of IPG. Every consolidation story gets covered as a scale or capability story. It’s rarely covered as an accountability story, which is the gap worth naming.
When a platform or agency you rely on gets absorbed into a larger entity, the specific person who understood your setup, and the specific team accountable for a commitment made pre-merger, both routinely change without much warning. That’s the same accountability-drift pattern running through When Consultancies Overwhelm Business Leadership, just triggered by a different mechanism. A merger doesn’t automatically create the problem. It does remove the continuity that was quietly preventing it.
Every Media Guide Perspective article
-

Why Retention Stops At Loyalty
Most retention strategies stop at the loyalty program, the easiest mechanism to build. Here’s why that’s only half…
-

Why most integration programs fail after the deck is approved
The work that decides whether an M&A deal delivers starts the day after signing, and almost nobody is…
-

Six Free Executive Playbooks, Built From Repeated Problems
Six free executive playbooks on CDP business cases, operating models, retention, cold-start growth, FSI marketing and M&A integration…
-

Media Guides is not an agency. It never should have tried to look like one.
Media Guides is repositioning as a strategic advisory practice, not a media agency or an editorial site. Here’s…
-

When Consultancies Overwhelm Business Leadership
A consultancy engagement is supposed to sharpen a decision. Too often it replaces one, with a framework, a…
-

A Four-Month Retrospective Of Google’s Cookie Conundrum
This was originally a snapshot taken four months into Google’s cookie deprecation rollout. The rollout didn’t finish. It…
-

Retail Media Networks and Their Impact on Attribution
Retail media networks sell the placement and grade their own homework on whether it worked. That’s not unique…
-

Traffic Value In The Artificial Intelligence Era
A page ranking first in Google used to mean a predictable share of clicks. With an AI Overview…
-

Unraveling the SaaS Proposals of Magnite and PubMatic
In 2023, sell-side sources told Digiday that Magnite and PubMatic were quietly testing SaaS-style fees. Both companies declined…
-

The Role of Adtech in the Privacy Sandbox Era
As the marketing landscape shifts towards more privacy-centric practices, the Adtech industry is gearing up for significant changes.
-

Why Brand Marketers Now Need to Influence The Influencers
Marketers once determined how their brands were presented, perceived, and promoted. Nowadays, they find themselves influencing the influencers.
-

Marketing Value And Transparency: A Call to Action for CMOs
Marketing value today hinges on how effectively CMOs can cultivate trust by embracing honesty and clarity in every…
-

Navigating M&A, Privacy Sandbox & Alternatives As The Cookie Crumbles
For six years, the digital advertising industry planned around a specific assumption: Chrome would deprecate third-party cookies, and…
-

Balancing The Strengths And Limitations Of LLMs For Marketers
Advertising has evolved from a simple “business of words” to a sophisticated realm of digital technologies. We explore…
-

A Marketing Perspective On The Attention Dichotomy
A guide to the attention dichotomy, where good attention fosters engagement and bad attention repels consumers
-

Martech Turf Wars: Maximizing Your Technology Investment
Most martech underperformance isn’t a tooling problem. It’s an ownership problem, marketing, IT and sales operations each holding…
-

How to Balance Data Privacy and Marketing Attribution
Privacy and attribution get framed as opposing forces, more of one meaning less of the other. That’s not…
-

Why The Middle Manager Is Pivotal To Your Success
We explore the critical role of middle managers and offer insights into how businesses can better support them…
-

Is Generative AI Good or Bad for Your Businesses?
The shift from traditional to digital media is a cornerstone for business growth, shaping how enterprises connect with…
-

From Traditional to Digital: Marketing in the Information Era
The shift from traditional to digital media is a cornerstone for business growth, shaping how enterprises connect with…
-

Building Strong Brands: The Essentials for Driving Growth
As the media industry becomes increasingly dominated by buzzwords, many businesses find themselves swept up in the hype,…
-

Subscription Models In Media And Journalism
Subscription and membership revenue is publishers’ clear top priority in 2026, ahead of both display and native advertising.…
-

Remote Work: The New Normal?
Remote work, once considered a luxury or exception, is the new norm for many employees. Its clear the…
-

Interactive Marketing: Engaging Audiences and Driving Results
With information overload and intense competition for user engagement, businesses and marketers are turning to interactive marketing as…
-

Exploring the Psychology of Colors in Consumer Behavior
Colors play a crucial role in our daily lives. They have the power to evoke emotions, capture attention,…
-

Strategies for Customer Retention Success
As a business owner or marketer, it’s no secret that acquiring new customers can be a costly and…
-

How Storytelling Transforms Brand Building
“Storytelling triggers oxytocin” gets repeated in marketing content constantly, usually stripped of the actual research behind it. The…
-

Consolidating Media Ownership & Journalistic Integrity
Media ownership consolidation is a phenomenon that has significantly transformed the landscape of media industries worldwide. In this…
-

The Evolution of Programmatic Advertising: Billboards to Bots
Programmatic advertising has emerged as a revolutionary force in the digital marketing world. This cutting-edge technology, powered by…
Not sure where to start in the archive?
Our hand-picked pieces on adtech, data privacy, AI governance and martech, curated for depth, not just recency, with a quick summary of the key themes in each.
Get it when there’s something worth reading
Sent when there’s a story, stat or tool worth your time, not on a schedule for its own sake. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Put the thinking into practice
Featured Sales
Software, course and electronics deals worth knowing about, curated the same way the opinions above are.
See current deals >Tech & Services Comparison
Weigh up the platforms and vendors behind a lot of these arguments before you commit to one.
Compare providers >Frequently asked questions
What does “The Media Guide Perspective” actually cover?
Opinion pieces that take a position: on consultancy overreach into business leadership, platform accountability (Google and Meta’s ad refund practices, made-for-advertising sites), the limits of AI and LLMs for marketers, retail media attribution, and martech decisions that don’t hold up under scrutiny.
How is this different from State of the Market?
State of the Market tracks what’s happening and why it’s commercially significant. The Media Guide Perspective is where we argue a point of view on it, including calling out practices we think are bad for the industry.
Are these Tim’s personal opinions, or The Media Guides’ official position?
Both. This is a solo practice, so the perspective published here is the same one applied in advisory engagements, not a separate editorial voice.
How often is this archive updated?
Whenever there’s a position worth taking, not on a fixed schedule. The archive above pulls every article in this category automatically, so it’s always current.
Do these opinions connect to the advisory work you do?
Often, yes. Several of these arguments, particularly on martech decisions, AI governance and platform accountability, come directly from work covered on Business Challenges.
Accessibility Adtech AI Analytics Art & Science Attribution Brand Lift Brand Loyalty Commercial Strategies Content Strategies Content Strategy Contextual CRO Culture Customer First Customer Journey Data Data-Driven Creativity Data Governance Data Powered Digital Marketing Digital Transformation Disruption Efficiency Ethics Featured Guides Innovation Marketing Best Practice Martech Operations Partnerships Performance Marketing Personalization Planning Platforms Products Retail Media Segmentation SEO Small Business Social Media Tech Enablement Test & Learn Yield
THE MEDIA GUIDES IS YOUR PORTAL TO THOUGHT PROVOKING & INSIGHTFUL EDITORIAL
While you’re here, explore our other news, guides & partner offers to supercharge your personal and professional growth.

State of the Market
Whether you’re a business professional, a news enthusiast, or simply curious about the world around you, ‘State of the Market’ is your compass to understanding the state of our dynamic digital media industry.

Insights that Inspire
Our team of industry experts and thought leaders are at the forefront of media trends and innovation. We bring you the latest insights and analyses, providing you with a clear roadmap to navigate the complex media landscape, from social media strategies to content marketing and beyond.

Resources to Unleash Your Brand’s Potential
Explore our Marketing & Advertising guides to supercharge your organization. Whether you’re a seasoned entrepreneur or just starting out, the Media Guides will propel your business to new heights.

Unleash your brand’s potential
Explore our curated collection of exclusive offers and discounts from our trusted partners in the digital media industry. Boost your online presence and maximize your marketing ROI with our partner network.










You must be logged in to post a comment.